What Did You Go Out to See?

by | Dec 10, 2025 | Advent, Blog, Devotional

Matthew 11:2-9

Jesus asks the people gathered around him, “When you went out to hear John the Baptizer “What did you go out into the wilderness to see?”

This is an important question for us as we approach Christmas: What are we seeking in celebrating Christ’s birth? Are we simply hoping for the magic of Christmas, like maybe you felt when you were a kid? Is Christmas for you about sharing gifts with family, songs and carols of the season playing all day, capped with a wonderful dinner? Or is there more to it for you?

A number of years ago, I had a fascinating conversation with a woman who was a member of the Church of God in Christ (COGIC). Many COGIC churches do not celebrate Christmas as they don’t see any rationale for it in the Scriptures and they view it as being wrapped in pagan rituals. To be clear, COGIC does believe in the Trinity, the virgin birth, and the incarnation. They just don’t do Christmas.

I was quite surprised by this and asked her many follow-up questions, like:

  • What do you do to recognize the birth of Jesus? If so, when, how?
  • Do you recognize the season of Advent?
  • Do you sing any Christmas carols? Do you wish you could share in it?

I didn’t even bother to ask about the practice of giving gifts.

She said that since she has never recognized Christmas, she doesn’t miss what she never experienced. She observes all the stress and expense people go through at this time of year and are pretty happy not to have to deal with it. Basically, her church accepts all the significance of Jesus’ presence without all the “drama.”

I have always loved this time of year, particularly the season of Advent, the time of preparation. Yes, it bothers me that Jesus’ birth is being used by businesses to make a profit, but I try to tune out the crassness as much as I can. I also need to admit that, for me, Christmas Day has been somewhat bittersweet. The day is fun, but afterwards there is nothing to look forward to… at least until Lent, which is not quite the same.

So I ask again, “What are we seeking in the celebration of Christ’s birth?” This is something each of us needs to answer for ourselves.

Gracious God,
Help us to tune out all the distractions and noise of these days, and focus on the pure joy of your coming into the world as one of us. Amen.

Pictures from Silver Bay 2026

Pictures from Silver Bay 2026

We gathered at Silver Bay in early June for a time of rest, reflection, and connection. Enjoy these glimpses of our time together! If you have pictures to share, please send them to us and we will add them to our website. Thank you!

Gun Violence Prevention Worship & Discussion Recordings

Gun Violence Prevention Worship & Discussion Recordings

The Albany Presbytery Peacemaking Task Force Gun Violence Prevention Event recordings are now available. Our guest preacher and presenter was The Rev. Margery Rossi, Minister for Gun Violence Prevention, Presbyterian Peace Fellowship and Pastor, South Presbyterian...

Threads of Opportunity in Guatemala | Self-Development of People

Threads of Opportunity in Guatemala | Self-Development of People

I have been aware of the Self-Development of People (SDPO) fund since it was established in the early 70's. I always thought it was a great idea, a great way to provide support that respects and builds on people’s own leadership, but I've also been aware of many times...

2026 Anti-Racism Civil Rights Pilgrimage

2026 Anti-Racism Civil Rights Pilgrimage

September 28 – October 5, 2026 Where: Centered in Montgomery, Alabama Estimated Cost: $2,000 Scholarships: Scholarships are available to help make participation possible. Deposit: $200 (payable to Albany Presbytery by June 1) Payments: Make out your check to Albany...

Supporting the ASAP Act for a Cleaner New York

Supporting the ASAP Act for a Cleaner New York

A Message from Albany Presbytery's Peacemaking Task Force On March 9 and 10, the NYS Council of Churches (NYSCOC) held its annual Ecumenical and Interfaith Advocacy Days led by the NYSCOC Environmental Justice Working Group. The Working Group stated that "A failure to...

About the author

Rev. Dr. Tim Coombs serves as co-pastor of Trinity Presbyterian Church in Scotia, NY with his wife, Rev. Kathleen Gorman-Coombs and is the current Vice Moderator of Albany Presbytery. Besides his work for the church, Tim is a storyteller, guitar player, and grandfather.
View More Posts By Rev. Dr. Tim Coombs