Beware of Email Scams Targeting Church Leaders

by | Mar 6, 2025 | News

We want to inform our community of an ongoing email scam affecting Albany Presbytery. Scammers are impersonating church leaders—currently our Moderator, The Rev. Dr. Katy Stenta—by sending fraudulent emails that appear to come from her. These emails typically ask recipients to respond regarding a confidential matter. The sender’s email address is not legitimate, though it may look similar to an official one.

What You Need to Know

  • These scams are not unique to Albany Presbytery—similar impersonation attempts have targeted churches and faith organizations nationwide.
  • The scammers appear to be gathering names and contact details from our website.
  • The emails change frequently, but they typically create a sense of urgency and request a direct reply.

A Couple of Email Examples

Fake email examples 1

How You Can Stay Safe

  • Double-check email addresses. If you receive a request for private information or an unusual favor, verify that the sender’s email is correct. Albany Presbytery leaders use official email accounts, not random addresses. At this time, our Moderator and Vice Moderator use their personal email address.
  • Do not reply or click on any links in suspicious emails.
  • Be cautious of emails requesting access to church or presbytery directories. Scammers may try to obtain contact lists to target more people.
  • Report suspicious emails to us. If you receive an email that seems off, please let us know so we can continue to monitor the situation.

We are sorry for any confusion this may cause. Unfortunately, we have no control over these fraudulent emails, but we want to ensure everyone is informed and prepared. While Rev. Katy Stenta is the current target, scammers may attempt to impersonate other leaders in the future.

If you have any concerns, please reach out to us directly. Thank you for your vigilance in keeping our community safe!

Clergy Self-Care: An Oxymoron?

Clergy Self-Care: An Oxymoron?

For many of us, the words Clergy and Self-Care are incongruous, a paradox, impossible and yet critical. In August 2022, the PC(USA) published an article titled, Rest is Resistance.1 The following is an excerpt: “After earning a PhD and teaching for a few years, Dr....

Storm at Sea

Storm at Sea

In my mid-twenties I was a new Navy Reservist on a training mission in the Mid-Atlantic. It was late fall and we were going through a storm at sea. I had been assigned to lookout duty on the aft section of the ship. When my duty was over, and I was going to return to...

New Breath Spirituality Center: A New Place to Experience God

New Breath Spirituality Center: A New Place to Experience God

“Experiencing God’s presence, together.” What is New Breath Spirituality Center? A new ministry has started in the Albany Presbytery called New Breath Spirituality Center, and its goal is to connect people with God and with one another through spiritual practices and...

It’s Closer, It’s Coming Our Way!

It’s Closer, It’s Coming Our Way!

This painting by James Tissot (1836-1902) is hosted in the Brooklyn Museum, New York. A scan of this image has been released into the public domain and digitally enhanced and resized for projection by FreeBibleimages. It is made available for free download under a...

Love Came Down at Christmas

Love Came Down at Christmas

"And Mary treasured all these words and pondered them in her heart."—Luke 2:19 Tim and I found out I was pregnant with our first child at the beginning of Advent in 1986. I announced the pregnancy to my family on the same day I was ordained, November 20 of that year....

About the author

Albany Presbytery strives to provide relevant information. If you have any questions, you can contact us via email at [email protected].