Beware of Email Scams Targeting Church Leaders

by | Mar 6, 2025 | News

We want to inform our community of an ongoing email scam affecting Albany Presbytery. Scammers are impersonating church leaders—currently our Moderator, The Rev. Dr. Katy Stenta—by sending fraudulent emails that appear to come from her. These emails typically ask recipients to respond regarding a confidential matter. The sender’s email address is not legitimate, though it may look similar to an official one.

What You Need to Know

  • These scams are not unique to Albany Presbytery—similar impersonation attempts have targeted churches and faith organizations nationwide.
  • The scammers appear to be gathering names and contact details from our website.
  • The emails change frequently, but they typically create a sense of urgency and request a direct reply.

A Couple of Email Examples

Fake email examples 1

How You Can Stay Safe

  • Double-check email addresses. If you receive a request for private information or an unusual favor, verify that the sender’s email is correct. Albany Presbytery leaders use official email accounts, not random addresses. At this time, our Moderator and Vice Moderator use their personal email address.
  • Do not reply or click on any links in suspicious emails.
  • Be cautious of emails requesting access to church or presbytery directories. Scammers may try to obtain contact lists to target more people.
  • Report suspicious emails to us. If you receive an email that seems off, please let us know so we can continue to monitor the situation.

We are sorry for any confusion this may cause. Unfortunately, we have no control over these fraudulent emails, but we want to ensure everyone is informed and prepared. While Rev. Katy Stenta is the current target, scammers may attempt to impersonate other leaders in the future.

If you have any concerns, please reach out to us directly. Thank you for your vigilance in keeping our community safe!

Introducing Rev. Matt McGraw

Introducing Rev. Matt McGraw

We are pleased to welcome The Rev. Matt McGraw to Albany Presbytery as pastor of Delmar Presbyterian Church. Get to know Matt, his family, and the journey that brought them from Texas to the Capital District, and discover what he is most excited about as he begins...

Introducing CRE Michael Barron

Introducing CRE Michael Barron

We are pleased to introduce Commissioned Ruling Elder (CRE) Michael Barron, who is serving at First United Presbyterian Church of Salem. Take a few moments to learn more about his background, his journey to ministry, and what he looks forward to as he and the...

Collisions: Reflections on a Holocaust Pilgrimage

Collisions: Reflections on a Holocaust Pilgrimage

Save the Date: Saturday, September 26 at 1:00 pm Click here for event details The word collision entered the English language in the early 15th century, stemming from the Late Latin word collisionem, meaning “a dashing together.” The original literal root of collision...

Pictures from Silver Bay 2026

Pictures from Silver Bay 2026

We gathered at Silver Bay in early June for a time of rest, reflection, and connection. Enjoy these glimpses of our time together! If you have pictures to share, please send them to us and we will add them to our website. Thank you!

About the author

Albany Presbytery strives to provide relevant information. If you have any questions, you can contact us via email at [email protected].